Star Trek: Discovery - Terra Firma Part 1 Review

DIS "Terra Firma Part 1"

The first episode of Discovery, "The Vulcan Hello", began with a cold open of Shenzou First Officer Michael Burnham and Captain Philippa Georgiou, bantering as a two woman landing party on a strange new world. "Terra Firma Part 1" recreates that dynamic, even though Georgiou is represented by her Terran Mirror self, and Burnham is no longer First Officer of anything. It's a fitting callback, but is emblematic of an episode that looks back at the expense of going forward.

This third season has thrived when using the new dynamics of the show to establish a new center of gravity for the show. I have been slightly resistant to any element from the first two seasons potentially slowing that roll. So when Georgiou finds herself back in the Mirror Universe, indeed in the backstory to the events we picked up there in Season 1, it feels like going backward.

Indeed, everything in this first part of a two-parter leads up to the moment when Georgiou, with the benefit of a more "evolved" consciousness, makes a different choice and doesn't execute Mirror Burnham. That choice changes things and brings the story into uncharted territory, serving to make Part 1 something of a no-frills setup for what's to come.

The essential problem with the Mirror stuff in this episode is that it replaces plot with posturing. Yes, the aesthetics are very effective, it's great to return to Captain Killy, Landry's back, there's a play within a play, everyone's wearing too much eyeliner, and even the maintenance robots are shadowy. While the arch scenery-chewing has always been the delicacy of Mirror Universe episodes, there's not a lot to the setting as presented here beyond that. 

There are the mixed feelings Georgiou seems to feel in her homecoming. For one thing, her slightly softer edges account for her uncommon civility toward the enslaved Saru. It's almost like the Georgiou of the season so far has protested too much, that her sadism was a bit of a front, some useful branding, and that confronted with her old life, she doesn't embrace it with open arms.

The episode begins with an expository scene with Culber and David Cronenberg's Kovich, and there are few actors on this show I'd rather hear exposition from than Cronenberg. Any sinister undertone to Kovich from his last appearance appears to be a red herring at this point. Dude just knows the Mirror Universe. (And the events of 2009's Star Trek film, as he alludes to Nero's incursion in time.) Elsewhere, the Burn-relevant distress call is revealed to be Kelpien in origin.

While the plot device of the doorway and the affably enigmatic Carl just screams, "We're being SURREAL!", it's novel. (Like a workaday Guardian of Forever.) That puts it in contrast to most of the episode, which has a lot of Terran pomp and circumstance but proves slightly hollow. Now that Georgiou has splintered the timeline by sparing Burnham, hopefully Part 2 triangulates how to tell a more dynamic Mirror Universe story. 5/10.