Star Trek Randomized Rewatch: Carbon Creek

ENT "Carbon Creek"

In one of the most memorable moments of "Carbon Creek", Mestral tells his two fellow Vulcan comrades stranded in late 1950s Pennsylvania that he doesn't want to miss I Love Lucy later that night. It's a good joke, but it doubles as a tribute to Lucille Ball, without whom Star Trek would not have been greenlit. When Star Trek was created, its writers did not foresee an episode like "Carbon Creek", a low-stakes tale of advanced Vulcans learning to smell the primitive American roses, with all the edginess of plankton. But that very inoffensiveness is arguably a selling point of the episode as well.

The events are framed as T'Pol telling a story, of her ancestor and two shipmates who crashed on Earth, to Archer and Trip over a dinner celebrating her one year anniversary on Enterprise. Jolene Blalock plays T'Pol and her ancestor T'Mir, the latter with real Beth Harmon energy. The Vulcan character most sympathetic to the humans is Mestral, played by J. Paul Boehmer (who also essayed a sympathetic Borg drone in, er, "Drone").

The small town Carbon Creek setting is established musically by Jay Chattaway. He uses rustic instrumentation, and perhaps anachronistically, a fretless bass most associated with 1990s crooning ballads. In a jarringly racy moment, T'Mir changes behind a cloth, and her silhouette goes even further than Jessica Rabbit in its cartoonish details. I'm surprised it was allowed on cable, but who am I kidding? UPN probably pushed for it.

At its heart, "Carbon Creek" is an immigrant story. The Vulcans are strangers in a strange land. In contrast with the other two surveyors, who are eventually extracted and return to Vulcan, Mestral stays because of his affinity for the people of Earth. Again, the stakes are low, but a hangout feel isn't a bad thing. Yes, there's a cave-in, and T'Mir invents velcro, but "Carbon Creek" is a light episode, light as a cloud. 5/10.

Stray observation:

- In the talk discussing the true first contact between humans and Vulcans, mention is made of the Zefram Cochrane statue in Bozeman, Montana. That statue was first mentioned by Geordi in Star Trek: First Contact.